Ask ten guitar teachers which type of guitar a beginner should start on and you'll get ten different answers. The truth is there's no single right answer — but there is a right answer for you. Here's how to figure out which one that is.
The case for starting on acoustic
Acoustic guitars have a lot going for them as a first instrument. They're completely self-contained — no amp, no cables, no extra gear to buy or set up. You can sit on the couch and play. Take it camping. Busk at the markets. Acoustic players tend to develop strong finger technique quickly, largely because the strings require a bit more pressure to fret cleanly.
Acoustic is ideal if you love: folk, country, singer-songwriter, fingerpicking, classical, or just want the simplest possible setup.
The downside? Steel-string acoustics can be tough on fingertips in the first few weeks. Your fingers will toughen up — every guitarist goes through this — but it can feel discouraging at first.
The case for starting on electric
Electric guitars are often overlooked as a beginner option, but they're actually very forgiving to learn on. The strings are lighter and sit closer to the fretboard, which means less finger pressure and less discomfort for new players.
Electric is ideal if you love: rock, blues, metal, pop, funk, or any guitar-driven genre where electric is the dominant sound.
The catch is cost. You'll need an amp and a cable to play properly, which adds to your startup investment. A small practice amp doesn't need to be expensive — there are solid options under $100 — but it's something to factor in.
What about classical guitar?
Classical guitars use nylon strings instead of steel, which are much softer on fingers. This makes them a popular choice for young children and absolute beginners who find steel strings uncomfortable. The trade-off is that classical technique is quite specific — the right-hand position and posture are different from standard acoustic or electric playing. If you're interested in classical music or flamenco, it's a great starting point. If you're chasing a rock or pop sound, you'll eventually want to move to steel strings.
Does it matter which you start on?
Not as much as you might think. The fundamentals of guitar — chords, scales, rhythm, music theory — apply across all types. Many guitarists start on one and comfortably switch to the other. Your technique won't be ruined by starting on the "wrong" type.
What matters far more is that you actually enjoy playing it. A guitar that excites you is a guitar you'll pick up. A guitar that bores you or frustrates you is one that ends up in the corner.
Our honest advice
If you're buying for a child: consider a classical or 3/4 acoustic for the softer strings and manageable size.
If you love rock, metal, or blues: start electric. You'll progress faster on the music you love.
If you love folk, country, or acoustic-driven pop: start acoustic. It's simpler and more portable.
If you genuinely can't decide: come into Mooloolaba Music Centre and play both. There's no substitute for holding an instrument and seeing which one feels right. Our team will give you an honest recommendation — not just try to sell you the more expensive option.
Visit us at Shop 5, 2 Kensington Drive, Minyama QLD, open 7 days.